User ID
Password
New User  Forgot Password   
 
Search  
Back   
Aphorism 8
§8

It is not conceivable, nor can it be proved by any experience in the world, that, after removal of all the symptoms of the disease and of the entire collection of the perceptible phenomena, there should or could remain anything else besides health, or that the morbid alteration in the interior could remain uneradicated*.

Foot Note:
EXPLANATION
HAHNEMANN'S TIME
Top
This aphorism is a rejoinder to the Hufeland's statement that “Homoeopathy removes symptoms only and the disease remains as it is”. Here Hahnemann says that there is no proof that the disease remains after removal of the symptoms. He blames the materialistic concept of disease of the old school for this thinking. Hahnemann insists that logically, only after the removal of the external expression of the internal disturbance of the body the person should be termed as red and restored to health.
MODERN RELEVANCE
As the concept of disease has changed over a period of time one would be tempted to say the other way round that in today's practice the doctor is more interested in making the blood chemistry of the patient normal than the patient himself. As we now understand that if the exciting cause and the precipitating factors persist then the patient cannot be termed as to be cured or normal. In a case of hypertension the patient was repeatedly complaining of giddiness and uncomfortable sensation at the chest. When his blood pressure came down the physician was thrilled, but his other above complaints remained, so the term patient is cured is wrong.